Examiners report on phd thesis download

The candidate should not be awarded the degree of phd. Once posted, the thesis is forwarded through the gps navigation towards the exterior and internal examiners, wholl in the end send a readers report roughly 30 days. Research supervision is still a difficult and often unacknowledged process, with supervisors getting minimal credit. Examiners are expected to take up to six weeks to examine the thesis and must return their examiners report to the graduate research office. Examiners report continued d grounds for recommendation please state the grounds on which you base your recommendation relative to the statements about the content and presentation of the thesis in a above. Review report on the phd thesis submitted to maria curie. Please use this form to report the outcome of your examination. From an extensive investigation of thesis examination practices among examiners of australian doctoral theses holbrook et al. At scu, when both phd examiners comment on the outstanding nature of a phd thesis, the candidate may be eligible to receive special acclamation, known as the chancellors medal for outstanding phd thesis.

Several important issues affecting the catalyst performance are addressed with the focus on the relationship between the compositionstructuremorphologyactivity. As academic readers, examiners favour a thesis with a convincing approach that engages with the literature and the findings, but they require a thesis to be publishable research. Traditionally, examiners reports on theses at the doctoral and masters level consist of two components. Once the faculty has appointed two examiners for the licentiate thesis, the examiners have two months to submit to the faculty a written, reasoned statement 24 pages, either individually or jointly, recommending either the approval or rejection of the thesis. Evaluation and instruction in phd examiners reports. Scrutiny of phd examining is increasingly coming under managerial attention, and possibly. Qualities and characteristics in the written reports of doctoral. The first level is the coding categories that emerged out of reading the report text. Examiners may use the space below to make a recommendation where they have identified research excellence in the thesis, only where the recommendation is a that the degree of phd be awarded with no corrections or b that the degree of phd be awarded subject to editorial and presentational corrections. Guidelines for examiners of theses submitted for the degree of doctor of philosophy phd please note that your report will initially be released to those involved in the examination process, other than the candidate. In that respect, the thesis bychapter format may be advantageous, particularly for students pursuing a phd in the natural sciences, where the research content of a thesis consists of many discrete experiments.

When the results of this study are written up as a paper to be submitted for publication, i will extend. There are five broad categories of codes that capture. Gerry mullins and margaret kiley 2002 in its a phd, not a nobel prize. Degree of doctor of philosophy examiners report on. Examiners report on masters thesis university of auckland. Mentorship cost claim form under dst inspire scheme. When the completed examinersreports have been returned to gps, the procedures for masters theses and doctoral theses are as follows. Like any reader, thesis examiners get annoyed and distracted by presentation errors, and they want to read a work that is a coherent whole. The analysis draws on the examiner report data for 501 candidates. A template is available to guide examiners on how to structure their written report and will be provided with the thesis see examiners report on doctoral thesis template. Examiners comments on introduction chapter in theses. I wrote a brief report to limit unnecessary repetition, given the current format of the thesis whereby the study in chapter 2b directly follows that of chapter 2a. While thesis writing guidebooks advise candidates to treat criticism in an examiners report as something to make them stronger and the thesis better, and to respond to the required emendations in a fair and considered way e.

The medal is awarded when both examiners comment on the significance of the thesis and rank it in the top 5%. The external examiners report is submitted directly to the doctoral exams team at graduate and postdoctoral studies. The analysis demonstrates variations in the format, recommendations and interpretation of recommendations among the reports. Lynette vroomans phd thesis comments examiner number 1. I try in my reading of theses to understand where the student is coming from. Further the order of importance across indicators was essentially the same for the two levels of thesis. The vicechancellor, given names of three foreign examiners, three outside tn. Cardiac imaging has improved dramatically in the last few years. As a postgraduate candidate, you will never leave the viva hall after the viva without comments on your thesis. Previous research on examiners reports has, therefore, alluded to the notion of role in helping understand the nature of evaluation and instruction in examiners reports on phd theses, but, to date, there have been no linguisticallyled analyses of these roles within a large corpus of examiners reports. How to deal with postviva phd thesis corrections the. The evaluation part 2 of the report will be released the candidate once the board of graduto ate. Report on phd thesis of maxime sermesant by derek hill, may 2003 maxime sermesants thesis addresses the highly topical and innovative area of electromechanical models of the heart, and the use of these models for image analysis and simulation. Having read the thesis, both examiners produce an independent report.

Thesis examiners report for examiners thesis examiners report reexamination notice of thesis submission. A recent experience in being an external examiner for a phd thesis was a most distressful experience which went on for a period of several months covering four. This paper outlines the procedures used in the textual analysis of examiner reports for 101 phd candidates across disciplines in one australian university. This article investigates the expectations of the literature in research and scholarship at ph. Although this guide focuses mostly on phd examining, most of the points within it will also. External examiner s report name of the thesis candidate. If it becomes evident that this will not be possible, please notify us immediately reports and examiners recommendation form including the scores for each of the six criteria should be emailed to the graduate research school. In this article, 51 examiners reports of doctoral theses are qualitatively analysed for common themes. Madras university unearths foreign phd examiner mafia. In cases where examiners are not unanimous in their recommendations, a.

A duplicate from the phd thesis will be delivered to each examiner through the. Examiners should not include their final recommendation in the body of their thesis assessment report. Guidance for examiners of postgraduate research awards. Alternative method of phd thesis examination research mode. According to these reports, there might be additional corrections or changes to. Doing your amendments without losing heart or your mind. Examiners are asked to return their report within six weeks of receiving a thesis. Thesis examiners graduate and postdoctoral studies.

Phd thesis examiner guidelines the university of auckland. External examiners report graduate school university. Stella lacovides university of the witwatersrand, johannesburg,south africa general notices. Findings showed the examiners generally rated the relative importance of the indicators very similarly at both degree levels. Information in this section to be entered by faculty staff examiner s recommendation thank you for agreeing to examine the attached masters thesis research portfolio. I got category two for my phd, but both examiners checked the outstanding work box which made me feel better.

External examiner report on doctoral dissertation for phd degree. As a thesis examiner, you will complete this form and attach a written report providing a detailed justification of your evaluation. Clarity is paramount when determining the structurelayout of your dissertation. D masters theses is a summative assessment in which examiners have to assess theses and give comments based on guidelines given to the examiners, the expertise of the examiner, or both. External examiners report phd thesis proposal i help to. External examiners report name of the thesis candidate. Masters and phd examiners once you are studying at postgraduate level, an examiner is any person who evaluates some aspect of your coursework that will contribute to the final result of your course. The author has shown imagination is conceiving a research topic that contributes to current knowledge. Investigating phd thesis examination reports request pdf. The phd thesis of sylwia turczyniak is devoted to investigations of cobaltbased catalysts for ethanol steam reforming.

Internal examiners are sometimes responsible for the organisation of the viva and arrangements for the external examiners travel, accommodation and entertainment. The board of graduate studies relies on the examiners reports as a means of assessing whether or not the criteria for a phd degree listed in regulation 1e of the 2011 or 2016 phd. This means that, an examiner can be a faculty member in your department, a postdoctoral student, or even a researcher from another university. For some, it is hard to deal with the emotional and mental toll of having to spend yet more time working on the thesis. Theres no need to panic if you get category 1, 2 or 3 your thesis can still be considered of high quality. The work reported here draws on the responses of 353 phd and 74 research masters thesis examiners. Examination procedures when the thesis is sent for examination, the examiners have a minimum of four 4 weeks to evaluate the thesis and return the thesis examination reports. If it is not possible to complete the examination within this time frame please contact the graduate research office so that the candidate and supervisors can be kept informed of the examination progress.

The deadline to send this form and your written report to graduate and postdoctoral studies email. It is university policy to release to a candidate the report of each examiner identified by name. Examiners report on masters thesis research portfolio candidate name. Information in this section to be entered by faculty staff examiners recommendation thank you for agreeing to examine the attached masters thesisresearch portfolio. Lynette vroomans phd thesis comments examiner number 1 keywords. The examiners expect an abstract to be a succinct summary of the thesis which tells them what it is about and what is coming provides key details why the research was done, how, where and with whom, the results and the implications. The revisions that your examiners ask of you are the roadmap to a complete thesis. The reason for this is because the written thesis assessment report at massey university is regarded as stage 1 of the examination and the recommendation provides a guideline for the continuing examination process. The many and varied experiences of a phd examiner times. Qualities and characteristics in the written reports of doctoral thesis examiners allyson holbrook1, sid bourke, terence lovat, kerry dally university of newcastle abstract this paper outlines the procedures used in the textual analysis of examiner reports for 101 phd candidates across disciplines in one australian university. Examiners of higher degrees by research theses guidelines. Thesis examiners report for examiners thesis examiner s report reexamination notice of thesis submission. The thesis does not meet the aqf standard for award of doctor of philosophy or professional doctorate.

In cases where the external examiner recommends that a candidate proceed to oral defence, graduate and postdoctoral studies will normally distribute copies of the report to the graduate program advisor and all members of the examination committee one. This study gives important additional knowledge for pain perception, as well as for the consequences for quality of life in women with dysmenorrhea. Instructions for the examiners of doctoral dissertations. Examiners report on phd thesis writing i help to study. Sources say a few professors in delhi examine 150200 phd thesis from university of madras every year. The job of examining a phd involves several elements. The importance which examiners place on the editoral aspects of the theses is also highlighted. Qualities and characteristics in the written reports of. Phd degree is based on the submission of a satisfactory thesis. The examination at the university of canterbury has two stages. Understanding the language of evaluation in examiners. Kaedah alternatif pemeriksaan tesis doktor falsafah mod penyelidikan.